Xiu Xiu
Knife Play
2002 – 5 Rue Christine
Origin: San Jose, California
Style: Indie Electronic, Avant Garde

Listening to Knife Play is like walking into a room and staring down a triple homicide. You stand there, mouth agape, eyes wide as does, and the shock of what you are experiencing will soon enough sink in.
And whether you are comfortable or not in experiencing Jamie Stewart’s prose, it will be a difficult listen all the way through. And I use the term “difficult” on all levels.
As the first release for Xiu Xiu, Knife Play serves its purpose.
The album is infantile in approach compared to the grandeur the band possesses now. Sounds and songs become blurred after a while as the band keeps slashing away at values and norms. However, for a first album it’s a conscious effort with interesting effects and a firm planting in the Xiu Xiu paradigm, stripping themselves of the barriers that most people keep up for general safety.
We construct ourselves through an understanding of basic ignorance. Our finite knowledge in an infinite spectrum allows us to come to terms as to where we are in this spinning reality. And that’s where Stewart comes in, a balance between absolute truth and acceptance on what is at face value.
He challenges our levels of what it is we are willing to accept as art. Whether it be the shrapnel of clings and clanks and the sounds of knives knocking around like a wind chime or the explosive atonement of samples and distorted and contorted soundtrack effects to accompany the aural capacity of it all. There is nothing easy to this music.
But that is what impressed people like Jason Jackowiak of Splendid citing, “Rarely has a debut sounded as audaciously mangled and sophisticatedly brilliant as Knife Play” (http://www.splendidezine.com/review.html?reviewid=322409524029605).
And if you think that is it, you are sorely mistaken. Like on the song “I Broke Up (SJ),” Jamie Stewart expels his demons on abuse with a very realistic lyrical montage, where he practically jumps out of the speakers in anger and horror. He uses his voice like an instrument punctuating, mutilating or succumbing to the mood and circumstance he is dealing with.
And even though my copy of this release is used, there was a warning sticker on the label that stated: “when my mom died, I listened to Henry Cowell, Joy Division, Detroit Techno, the Smiths, Takemitsu, Sabbath, gamelan, ‘Black Angels’, and Cecil Taylor.” An interesting primer to what mindset Stewart was in, but also a disillusionment for people like Colleen Delaney from Stylus who reacted, “My beast ended up being a shrieking whiner playing a Casio and posing dramatically in front of a wall of black dollar store candles” (http://www.stylusmagazine.com/reviews/xiu-xiu/knife-play.htm). A little excessive there, I think, but not too incredibly off the mark.
This is an album that you will either accept or hate. You will take away something that gives you some kind of therapy or you will toss the disc away like a frisbee, repulsed by a degree of absurdity in the way the band concocted business, even though it’s the same business that other critics on the magazine ended up gushing over.
I just hope Stewart walked away a better person for this. If future releases indicates, I don’t have confidence that is what happened, as hard as he punches you in the face with his acidic dose of therapy.
Cross-Reference: The Paper Chase, Skinny Puppy, Third Eye Foundation